Similar games
Games like Pony Island
Daniel Mullins Games · 2016 · 95 % positive of 17,182
24 games that play like Pony Island and 24 that look like it. Closest by gameplay: Isolomus, INMOST and TAMASHII.
Player tags
At a glance
What games like Pony Island have in common
- The tags they share most often with Pony Island: Puzzle (17 of 24), Horror (17) and Psychological Horror (12).
- They came out between 2011 and 2026, 15 of them after Pony Island (2016).
- Best rated by Steam players: Endacopia (99 % positive of 8,289).
By gameplay
Plays like Pony Island
Matched from Steam descriptions and player tags. The tags under each game are the ones both games share.
Isolomus
95 % positive of 345
Shared: Puzzle · Psychological Horror · Horror
INMOST
91 % positive of 6,680
Shared: Puzzle · Psychological Horror · Pixel Graphics
TAMASHII
95 % positive of 329
Shared: Puzzle · Pixel Graphics · Horror
INSIDE
96 % positive of 68,046
Shared: Puzzle · Horror · Dark
LIMBO
92 % positive of 57,284
Shared: Puzzle · Horror · Dark
Closure
85 % positive of 978
Shared: Puzzle · Horror · Dark
Pinstripe
89 % positive of 2,526
Shared: Puzzle · Horror · Dark
Ugly
95 % positive of 495
Shared: Puzzle · Psychological Horror · Horror
Endacopia
99 % positive of 8,289
Forgotten Hill Mementoes
91 % positive of 236
Shared: Puzzle · Horror · Indie
Strangeland
93 % positive of 872
Shared: Psychological Horror · Pixel Graphics · Horror
ANIMAL WELL
95 % positive of 20,790
Shared: Puzzle · Pixel Graphics · Horror
More matches
- Stray Cat Crossing93 % positive of 641Shared: Puzzle · Psychological Horror · Pixel Graphics
- Darkestville Castle93 % positive of 633Shared: Puzzle · Demons · Story Rich
- Demons Never Lie92 % positive of 458Shared: Psychological Horror · Horror · Dark
- DISTRAINT: Deluxe Edition93 % positive of 12,242Shared: Puzzle · Psychological Horror · Pixel Graphics
- Dark Pals: The 1st Floor87 % positive of 829
- Toby: The Secret Mine70 % positive of 693Shared: Puzzle · Horror · Dark
- Plug & Play84 % positive of 4,898Shared: Puzzle · Psychological Horror · Horror
- Sally Face - Episode One97 % positive of 22,561Shared: Puzzle · Psychological Horror · Demons
- The Pony Factory91 % positive of 663Shared: Horror · Dark · Horses
- DERE EVIL EXE86 % positive of 382Shared: Psychological Horror · Pixel Graphics · Horror
- Bendy and the Ink Machine88 % positive of 29,290Shared: Puzzle · Psychological Horror · Horror
- Archimedes78 % positive of 216Shared: Psychological Horror · Hacking · Horror
By look
Looks like Pony Island
Matched from screenshots. Each card shows the screenshot closest to the look of this game.
Crossroad OS
98 % positive of 265
No Players Online
83 % positive of 697
Selfie : Sisters of the Amniotic Lens
60 % positive of 191
Minutescape
77 % positive of 249
SELF
77 % positive of 261
Tormenture
87 % positive of 167
Sorry, James
79 % positive of 844
You Have to Win the Game
92 % positive of 5,675
Buddy Simulator 1984
93 % positive of 3,951
THE ENIGMA MACHINE
91 % positive of 295
The Deadseat
97 % positive of 230
DEAD LETTER DEPT.
96 % positive of 791
More matches
- Bacteria57 % positive of 407
- The Message from Deep Space96 % positive of 1,902
- EMPTY SHELL88 % positive of 605
- EMPTY SHELL: PROLOGUE94 % positive of 1,367
- Voyager-1989 % positive of 750
- It Steals98 % positive of 2,065
- tERRORbane89 % positive of 355
- The Final Take64 % positive of 499
- Please, Don't Touch Anything 3D82 % positive of 1,301
- Gravity Wars56 % positive of 292
- This Strange Realm Of Mine82 % positive of 563
- CALENDULA76 % positive of 359
How these matches work
Matches come from embeddings of Steam descriptions, player tags and screenshots, computed offline. “Plays like” compares what the games are about and how players tag them; “Looks like” compares their screenshots. The share of positive reviews is based on Steam user reviews.