Similar games
Games like Puzzle Pirates
Grey Havens · 2011 · 80 % positive of 2,107
24 games that play like Puzzle Pirates and 24 that look like it. Closest by gameplay: Puzzle Pirates: Dark Seas, Puzzle Plunder and Uncharted Waters Online.
Player tags
At a glance
What games like Puzzle Pirates have in common
- The tags they share most often with Puzzle Pirates: Pirates (24 of 24), Strategy (9) and Co-op (8).
- They came out between 2005 and 2025, 21 of them after Puzzle Pirates (2011).
- Best rated by Steam players: Sid Meier's Pirates! (94 % positive of 6,894).
- Puzzle Pirates: Dark Seas and Puzzle Plunder both play and look like Puzzle Pirates.
By gameplay
Plays like Puzzle Pirates
Matched from Steam descriptions and player tags. The tags under each game are the ones both games share.
Puzzle Pirates: Dark Seas
74 % positive of 520
Shared: Massively Multiplayer · Puzzle · Pirates
Puzzle Plunder
85 % positive of 162
Shared: Puzzle · Pirates · Free to Play
Uncharted Waters Online
69 % positive of 401
Shared: Massively Multiplayer · Pirates · Strategy
Piratopia
84 % positive of 1,054
Shared: Massively Multiplayer · Pirates · MMORPG
Sea of Thieves: 2026 Edition
89 % positive of 355,238
Shared: Massively Multiplayer · Pirates · Co-op
The Pirate: Caribbean Hunt
82 % positive of 4,440
Shared: Pirates · Strategy · Free to Play
High Sea Saga DX
81 % positive of 407
Shared: Pirates · RPG · Casual
Sid Meier's Pirates!
94 % positive of 6,894
Shared: Pirates · Strategy · RPG
The Pirate: Plague of the Dead
77 % positive of 607
Shared: Pirates · Strategy · Free to Play
Arcane Waters
62 % positive of 172
Shared: Puzzle · Pirates · Co-op
The Caribbean Sail
94 % positive of 503
Shared: Pirates · Strategy · RPG
ATLAS
47 % positive of 42,534
Shared: Massively Multiplayer · Pirates · Co-op
More matches
- Windward79 % positive of 3,591Shared: Pirates · Strategy · Co-op
- Pixel Piracy65 % positive of 7,357Shared: Pirates · RPG
- Age of Booty™40 % positive of 200Shared: Pirates · Strategy · Casual
- Blazing Sails87 % positive of 9,710Shared: Pirates · Co-op · Multiplayer
- Salt 2: Shores of Gold87 % positive of 1,330Shared: Pirates · Adventure
- Don't Sink72 % positive of 212Shared: Pirates · RPG · Casual
- Maelstrom83 % positive of 2,572Shared: Massively Multiplayer · Pirates · Strategy
- King of Seas58 % positive of 744Shared: Pirates · RPG · Adventure
- Forgotten Seas81 % positive of 297Shared: Pirates · Co-op · Adventure
- Skull and Bones67 % positive of 1,704Shared: Pirates · Co-op · RPG
- Pirates of Black Cove66 % positive of 167Shared: Pirates · Strategy
- Tempest: Pirate Action RPG69 % positive of 2,517Shared: Pirates · Co-op · RPG
By look
Looks like Puzzle Pirates
Matched from screenshots. Each card shows the screenshot closest to the look of this game.
Puzzle Pirates: Dark Seas
74 % positive of 520
Sea Dogs
75 % positive of 156
Jolly Rover
88 % positive of 344
FATE
95 % positive of 4,075
Lilly and Sasha: Curse of the Immortals
79 % positive of 394
Puzzle Plunder
85 % positive of 162
Metal Assault
58 % positive of 298
Desktop Dungeons
84 % positive of 2,276
Echoes of Aetheria
83 % positive of 174
The Curse of Monkey Island
97 % positive of 2,745
Dark Scavenger
86 % positive of 243
Chantelise - A Tale of Two Sisters
75 % positive of 725
More matches
- Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick Obscura89 % positive of 1,804
- Fish Fillets 277 % positive of 288
- Patrician III82 % positive of 925
- Kohan II: Kings of War93 % positive of 257
- Recettear: An Item Shop's Tale96 % positive of 7,238
- Tidalis63 % positive of 236
- Plunder Panic84 % positive of 607
- Gladiator Guild Manager: Prologue93 % positive of 1,543
- Sacred Gold85 % positive of 4,210
- Citizens of Earth76 % positive of 399
- Epic Battle Fantasy 496 % positive of 3,158
- Epic Battle Fantasy 598 % positive of 5,603
How these matches work
Matches come from embeddings of Steam descriptions, player tags and screenshots, computed offline. “Plays like” compares what the games are about and how players tag them; “Looks like” compares their screenshots. The share of positive reviews is based on Steam user reviews.