Comparison guide
Games like Under The Island: similar indie games to play next
Under The Island works because fast decisions, readable runs, and meaningful progression all click together. This guide starts from those signals and links you directly to our full reviews.
Why these games fit Under The Island fans
Picked by shared tags, review scores, short verdicts, and editorial fit. The list is curated rather than a purely automatic sort.
8.3Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon - Sanctuary of Sarras DLC
Sunken secrets, new skill trees, 15 hours of content
Dec 15, 2025
If you liked Under The Island, Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon - Sanctuary of Sarras DLC delivers familiar action, adventure and exploration for a seamless next pick. We scored it 8.3/10.
Read the review →
7.6Cloudheim
Physics chaos, cozy shopkeeping, solid bones — needs polish.
Dec 4, 2025
Cloudheim leans into action, adventure and exploration, hitting the same notes that make Under The Island click. We scored it 7.6/10.
Read the review →
7.4Slime Rancher 2
Cozy visuals, cute slimes — marred by grind and travel.
Sep 23, 2025
